Prosjektnummer
901222
Development of a process for the automated heading and filleting of mackerel with a core temperature of below minus 1.5 °C using Japan-trim
Oppgradert teknologi for effektiv filetering av makrell med forskjellig type kutt. Teknologien er ikke tatt i bruk av bedriften, men kunnskapen er nyttig for videre- utvikling av effektiv filetering
• Det er mulig å installere en oppgraderingspakke til Baader 221 filetmaskin for produksjon av filet av halvfrosset makrellfilet.
• Teknologien er til salgs for selskap som ønsker å bruke ressurser på storskala produksjonstest med tilhørende feilretting.
• Helautomatisk fileteringsmaskin av halvfrosset makrellfilet forutsetter at råstoffet ikke er bøyd, men har naturlig form. Det er vanskelig ved bruk av frosset råstoff i perioder utenfor sesongen.
• Teknologien ble ikke implementert i næringsbedriften.
• Teknologien er til salgs for selskap som ønsker å bruke ressurser på storskala produksjonstest med tilhørende feilretting.
• Helautomatisk fileteringsmaskin av halvfrosset makrellfilet forutsetter at råstoffet ikke er bøyd, men har naturlig form. Det er vanskelig ved bruk av frosset råstoff i perioder utenfor sesongen.
• Teknologien ble ikke implementert i næringsbedriften.
Sammendrag av resultater fra prosjektets faglige sluttrapport
Det er utviklet oppgraderingspakke for Baader 221 filetmaskin som gjør det mulig å filetere halvfrosset makrell i følgende 5 varianter:
1. Kutting av hode foran kragebein, bukbein på, buklist på og innvoller følger med fileten
Det er mulig å filetere fisken på denne måten, men det forutsetter noen tekniske modifikasjoner. Disse kan imidlertid foretas av kunden uten nye deler fra Baader.
2. Kutting av hode gjennom sidefinne, bukbein på, buklist på, innvoller fjernet og svarthinne på
Dette er mulig uten noen modifikasjoner etter at den nye oppgraderingspakken er montert.
3. Kutting av hode gjennom sidefinne, uten bukbein, buklist på og innvoller fjernet
Dette er mulig å få til uten noen nødvendige modifikasjoner (hvis oppgraderingspakken er installert).
4. Kutting av hode bak sidefinne, uten bukbein, uten buklist, innvoller fjernet og uten svarthinne (Euro cut)
Dette er mulig uten noen nødvendige modifiseringer (dersom oppgraderingspakken er installert). Minimumstemperatur for trimming 4 er -3,5 °C. Gjennomsnittlig utbytte er 55 % av hel rund fisk.
5. Kutting av hode gjennom sidefinne, bukbein på, buklist på, innvoller fjernet og svarthinne delvis på
Dette er mulig uten nevneverdig modifiseringer hvis oppgraderingspakken er installert. Minimumstemperatur for trimming 5 er -3 °C. Gjennomsnittlig utbytte er 57 % av hel rund fisk.
Resultatene til tross, ble ikke den nyutviklede teknologien tatt i bruk av næringsbedriften. Teknologien i seg selv har gode muligheter for å kunne konkurrere med eksisterende teknologi for filetering av halvfrosset makrell. Teknologien er klart for salg og implementering. Testing og feilretting over tid i stor skala er imidlertid ikke blitt gjennomført. Årsaken er endring av strategi hos næringsbedriften, begrenset marked har redusert interessen for Baader til å bruke nødvendige ressurser på videre utvikling. Industriell sluttføring kan gjøres til næringsaktør som er villig til å inngå et nødvendig og forpliktende samarbeid om storskala utviklingstest.
Selv om teknologien ikke ble implementert og tatt i bruk av næringsbedriften, regnes prosjektet for nyttig. Det ble avklart at utvikling av en helautomatisk filetmasking innebærer betydelig innsats og kan være utfordrende. Spesielt er det vanskelig med tanke på automatisk innmating så lenge en ikke har kontroll på bøyd fisk (“bananfisk”) som skal inn i maskinen for filetering. Dette er et sentralt felt som må løses før helautomatisk innmating blir gjennomførbart for helårlig produksjon av makrellfilet.
-
Sluttrapport: Utvikling av prosess for automatisk hodekapping og filetering av makrell med kjernetemperatur lavere enn -1,5 °C for Japan-filet
Baader. Engelsk og norsk. 17. desember 2018. Av Tobias Washausen og Kjell Arthur Lind Olsen.
Background
Based on current information (2016), in 2015 about 300,000 tons of mackerel were landed in Norway. More than half of this volume (180,000 tons) was then dispatched unprocessed to Asia for further processing. Only about 2–3 % of the mackerel were filleted in Norway, which corresponds to about 7,000–10,000 tons. Due to market shifts towards high quality products, increasing labor costs in Asia and an increased use of by-products it is assumed that the market for mackerel fillets processed in Norway will grow steady in the next few years, which will lead to a share of 25 % of fillets processed in Norway in relation to the total quantity. This would correspond to about 75,000 tons of mackerel to be filleted in Norway. These numbers could grow even further should the catch quotas for mackerel increase in the next few years.
In order to guarantee a good level of freshness of the product over a long period, the Norwegian fishing industry has been seeking to first deep freeze the fish and only then to gently thaw them out in a controlled manner. Controlled thawing out ensures that the core temperature of the fish is below minus 1 °C during the entire process, the fish consequently remaining in effect frozen during the entire process.
The Norwegian fishing industry is constantly endeavoring to develop new sales markets for its products. In this process a possible new sales market for mackerel is in Japan, since the qualitative requirements for fillets in this market have been sharply rising for several years and the present producers, China and Vietnam, are having difficulties in meeting these increased quality requirements. At the same time, labor costs in these countries and costs for the transportation of the round mackerels are increasing fast. Both facts are making it very attractive for the Norwegian fishing industry to add more and more capacity to process the mackerels inland. This also opens a real opportunity for the Norwegian fishing industry with its high standards to establish its own products in the market and thereby generate new sales. At the same time the type of cuts required in the filleting process differ from the standard fillets.
Against this background there is a strong desire on the part of the Norwegian fisheries industry for suitable machines and processes which will put them in the position of being able to react to these future requirements of the market with the right concepts.
It is Baader's claim to find a solution that will still satisfy the Norwegian fish industry's high quality requirements for the end product. This is above all a clean cutting surface, combined with maximum yield.
At the same time the machine is to be capable of filleting the mackerel with the so-called Japan-trim, since a market for this exists which is to be supplied by the Norwegian fisheries industry.
The high throughput of fish (up to 150 fish/minute) leads in practice inevitably to a high cutting speed, which, combined with the high rigidity of the source product, can lead to problems in the filleting process. Due to the lower temperature of the fish in comparison with the current standard product the friction properties may also be altered, which under some circumstances makes modifications to the autofeeder necessary. In summary it can be said that the obtainable results will be seen to be heavily dependent on the condition of the commodity (for instance aging, gentle freezing and thawing). If the fish are not frozen in the stretched out state but have a ‘banana’ form, then it can be expected that the automatic input of the fish into the heading machine with the current autofeed concepts cannot be achieved without further development work going beyond the remit of this project. Likewise the heading and filleting of curved frozen mackerel is only possible to a certain degree. Therefore it strongly depends on optimizing the upstream processes such as the deep freezing of the commodity or installing an upstream sorting after the thawing out process so that only fish that are straight arrive at the filleting machine.
It is believed that for the vast majority of Baaders customers an upgrade kit for the processing of frozen commodities on existing machines would offer the greatest possible benefit in the short- and mid-term. Therefore such an upgrade kit is always favored in solving the problem.
In summary it is the aim of the project to design an optimal link in the process chain in processing frozen mackerel. The consistently high standards with respect to reliability, yield, quality and hygienic design are to be fully applied in this project so that the Norwegian fisheries industry can derive the greatest possible benefit from the newly emerging processing capabilities.
Objectives
To develop an upgrade kit for existing machines (BA 221) for the automated heading and filleting of mackerel with a core temperature of minus 1.5 °C to minus 2.7 °C.
Sub-objectives
• To process mackerel with a core temperature of minus 1.5 °C to minus 2.7 °C;
• To automatically feed the (unbent) mackerel into the heading section;
• To automatically head the mackerel;
• To automatically remove the mackerel viscera;
• To automatically fillet the mackerel at a speed of up to 150 fish per minute and using Japan-trim;
• To offer an upgrade kit for all existing Baader machines from type BA 221;
• To make a fully functional prototype of a upgrade kit available for field tests at the beginning of the season 2016;
• To make the upgrade kit available for sales in 2017.
• To process mackerel with a core temperature of minus 1.5 °C to minus 2.7 °C;
• To automatically feed the (unbent) mackerel into the heading section;
• To automatically head the mackerel;
• To automatically remove the mackerel viscera;
• To automatically fillet the mackerel at a speed of up to 150 fish per minute and using Japan-trim;
• To offer an upgrade kit for all existing Baader machines from type BA 221;
• To make a fully functional prototype of a upgrade kit available for field tests at the beginning of the season 2016;
• To make the upgrade kit available for sales in 2017.
Expected project impact
Baader is creating an option to automatically head mackerels with a core temperature of minus 1.5 °C to minus 2.7 °C, take the guts out and then fillet them using Japan-trim. In doing so it is absolutely vital from both an economic and ecological point of view to generate from the raw commodity a product that from the yield and quality aspects is optimal but at the same time is absolutely competitive via optimal use of a resource. In order not to miss market entry points and to keep investment costs low, an upgrade kit for conversion of existing machines is being developed by Baader that will be field tested in the 2016 catch season and will be available to the Norwegian fisheries industry by the 2017 catch season.
If the project ends up as a success it will give the industry increased income. The production capacity will increase from 30 fish/minute up to 150 fish/minute. It will at the same time decrease the number of workers and therefore decrease the production cost per kg fillet. This new technology will make it possible for the Norwegian pelagic industry to compete with low cost countries on price and quality.
By increasing the amount of fillet from Norway, the project will also reduce the amount of CO₂ in the atmosphere by less transport volume. By-products will be kept within the Norwegian industry for meal and oil and help the increasing salmon farming to get available marine protein and marine fatty acids.
The Norwegian fisheries industry will thus be placed in a position to develop new markets and extend its capacities in this sector. The results and experiences from the project can furthermore possibly be carried over for other applications, such as other fish species or fillet cuts, and thus also benefit other branches of the Norwegian fish industry.
Due to the intended development of an upgrade kit for existing production facilities, no modification will be necessary on the existing layout of the whole production line. Furthermore, existing automatic feeders can continue to be used, if necessary with slight modifications.
Project design and implementation
It is estimated that the development of a prototype can be finished in time for the beginning of the catch season in August 2016 and tests can be carried out under production conditions at Pelagia AS.
Any corrections resulting from these tests will be incorporated into the design and an upgrade kit ready for sale produced by August 2017. A detailed time schedule of the project can be found in the appendix.
Any corrections resulting from these tests will be incorporated into the design and an upgrade kit ready for sale produced by August 2017. A detailed time schedule of the project can be found in the appendix.
For carrying out the tests on site in Norway it is necessary for Pelagia AS to make available opportunities for the installation and running of the upgrade kit prototype and for supervision of the tests. Pelagia will also provide raw material (frozen mackerels) to perform the necessary tests. This will be regulated in a separate cooperation agreement.
The development will consist of three main phases:
1. Development of a prototype upgrade kit
During this phase, Baader will develop a prototype of the upgrade kit. Main contents of this phase is the concept development, the manufacturing of the prototype and internal tests at Baader's site.
Output: Ready to install prototype of the upgrade kit.
Estimated end: July 2016.
Estimated end: July 2016.
2. Test of the prototype under real conditions
The upgrade kit prototype will be shipped to Pelagia in Norway and there be installed on a existing BA 221. After finishing the installation, Baader will run the necessary tests to optimize and finish the prototype.
The upgrade kit prototype will be shipped to Pelagia in Norway and there be installed on a existing BA 221. After finishing the installation, Baader will run the necessary tests to optimize and finish the prototype.
Output: Well tested and fully functional prototype.
Estimated end: December 2016.
3. Final development of the ready to sell upgrade kit
With the lessons learned during phase 2, Baader will finish the development of the upgrade kit and then bring the kit to the Norwegian marked.
With the lessons learned during phase 2, Baader will finish the development of the upgrade kit and then bring the kit to the Norwegian marked.
Output: End of project and ready to sell upgrade kit.
Estimated end: June 2017.
Dissemination of project results
If other Norwegian companies is interested to know more about the new kit and how it works, Baader will inform these clients for free. This will be done after the project is finished and all results implemented.
Baader will make a short video (maximum 2–3 minutes) as a presentation of how the new fillet technology will work for production of Japan-trimmed mackerel fillets.
It will be made a report of how the adjusted Baader 221-machine works as far as the final results is concerned.
-
Sluttrapport: Utvikling av prosess for automatisk hodekapping og filetering av makrell med kjernetemperatur lavere enn -1,5 °C for Japan-filet
Baader. Engelsk og norsk. 17. desember 2018. Av Tobias Washausen og Kjell Arthur Lind Olsen.